Since then over half of those lots have been rehabilitated for homes, gardens, parks, orchards, playgrounds, schools, community centers, and a Town Common. By contrast, a party may obtain an equitable remedy when a court forces the other party to perform to its part of the contract. A community-based planning partnership launched a process in July 2014 to develop a set of Healthy Development Guidelines for the City of Oakland. Bringing together businesses with common needs permits the incubator greater efficiency in providing assistance. African . Also, EHC produced a video learning tool to share key lessons of community planning and community member involvement more broadly. For example, r e search from Harvard University shows that how easily a person can get to work is the strongest factor in determining whether a person escapes the . Teachers and administrators expressed concerns regarding grading English Learner (EL) students in a school district in a mid Atlantic state. The realization of the importance and necessity of addressing the human health and environmental issues of minority and low-income residents, and their relationship to human rights, is becoming more and more prominent but it is dependent upon active and sustained engagement from both the government and civil society at large. Through the workshop, EPA's Office of Environmental Justice and the Office of Sustainable Communities(now the Office of Community Revitalization) partner to deliver an interesting and informative program. A public investment strategy that addresses this inequity by equally distributing resources or only providing public amenities in response to market-led growth will only exacerbate inequitable outcomes. Racial inequities related to or resulting from displacement include: Equitable development ultimately manifests in tangible development projects and programs. Eliminate disproportionate environmental burdens and ensure an equitable share of environmental benefits for existing communities. has identified measures that show racial disparities in outcomes related to growth. Equitable development isn't a theoretical approach. developing a pathway for entry into racial equity work for new jurisdictions from across the country. Hiring goals call for 51 percent of new hires to be D.C. residents. To eliminate racial inequities in our communities, it is necessary to develop a collective impact approach firmly grounded in inclusion and equity. This project is a model for collaborative problem solving that shows how citizens can achieve extraordinary outcomes such as cleaning up two Superfund sites; managing vacant properties and brownfields; and conducting community design charettes. Throughout the nations history, some communities and neighborhoods prospered at the expense of others. equip architects' and designers' role in shaping equity in their work through equitable development frameworks consider a wide range of equitable development approaches differing in intersectionality, depth, structure, and relevance provide project examples to demonstrate the potential impacts each equitable development framework can establish In legal remedies, the non-breaching party can recover monetary damages. Practice meaningful community engagement. Measurable outcomes tracked over time with disaggregated data, reported on, and tied to performance can be an effective accountability strategy for improving government function to achieve equitable outcomes. The goal of the Equitable Development Plan is to ensure that the 11th Street Bridge Park is a driver of inclusive development - development that provides opportunities for all residents regardless of income and demography. Promote local economic development and entrepreneur opportunities, enhance community-serving establishments, and increase quality living wage jobs for people in all neighborhoods. As an approach, equitable development encourages fairness in planning and development practice to ensure everyone has a safe and healthy environment in which to live, work, and play. @TheConscious_ @ClinArk_Inc #DreamVision @NAACP #YouthCommittee #PromiseZoneCrew #GOPCThread, We are the Unified Collective. Preparation for this balance between competition and cooperation is critical. Become a member of Nonprofit Quarterly. Not less than 40 percent shall be allocated to households at or below 30 percent of the Districts median income; Not less than 80 percent of funds shall be allocated to households at or below 50 percent of the Districts median income; and. Equitable Development Planning - Joint Center for Housing Studies Sentences with the word : Synonyms. However, this view conceives of housing merely as a commodity or as a place of shelter so . For example, a Black woman with three young children is likely unable to take advantage of the same resources as a young, White man. Equitable Development Monitoring Program (EDMP) As outlined in the Equitable Development Implementation Plan, the EDMP is an ongoing source of data and analysis to inform City policies, programs, and investments - and to aid work within communities - to reduce race-based disparities, advance equity, and combat displacement. Here we set out five considerations that we think equitable infrastructure practitioners should take on board. Access. #GOPCThread, Another great approach 2 #EquitableDevelopment is happening in @fitchburgmass with #ReImagineNorthofMains resident leadership training programs #GOPCThread, Reimagine North of Main | Making Opportunity Count (click image for link), #ReImagineNorthofMains #ResidentLeadershipInstitute trains diverse professionals on leadership skills & helps place them @fitchburgmass decision-making tables. Grade retention rates of ELs were disproportionately high. Additional investments in culturally-specific commercial enterprises will also serve to maintain community integrity and make sure diversifying neighborhoods meet all the needs of a diverse population. UN-2 As recognized in the Copenhagen Declaration, social justice and equitable social development were essential for a process of sustainable development. neighborhoods, cities, counties) and groups (e.g. City officials, developers, policy makers, advocates, business owners and residents should expand their knowledge base, devise strategies, and form alliances that are deliberate in actively managing gentrification as well as the differential burdens that may beset populations and institutions that are less resilient to shifts in the market. By signing up, you agree to our privacy policy and terms of use, and to receive messages from NPQ and our partners. Shaw has become a very hot real estate market in Northwest D.C. in recent years. National Award for Smart Growth Achievement, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy in Low-Income Communities, Attracting Infill Development in Distressed Communities: 30 Strategies, Creating Equitable, Healthy, and Sustainable Communities: Strategies for Advancing Smart Growth, Environmental Justice, and Equitable Development, Unintended Impacts of Redevelopment and Revitalization Efforts in Five Environmental Justice Communities (PDF), The Model Plan for Public Participation (PDF), Environmental Justice Grants and Communities story map, Finding Federal Assistance and Resources for Environmental Justice Efforts, Resources for Creating Healthy, Sustainable, and Equitable Communities, Gullah Geechee Cultural Heritage Corridor Management Plan, Addressing Environmental Justice in EPA Brownfields Communities, 'brownfields at-a-glance', Paseo YMCA Cleanup Preserving History (PDF), Building Blocks for Sustainable Communities, Northwest Gardens - Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Bay Area Transit - Oriented Affordable Housing Fund - San Francisco Bay Area, California, Old North St. Louis Revitalization Initiative - St. Louis, Missouri, Smart.Growth@NYC: Policies and Programs for Improving Livability - New York City, Egleston Crossing - Roxbury, Massachusetts, Mission Creek Senior Community - San Francisco, California, Abyssinian Neighborhood Project - Borough of Manhattan, Harlem, New York, Pennsylvania Fresh Food Financing Initiative - Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, San Juan Pueblo Master Plan - San Juan Pueblo, New Mexico, Moore Square Museums - Raleigh, North Carolina, Connecting Smart Growth and Brownfields Redevelopment (PDF), Healthy, Equitable Transportation Policy: Recommendations and Research. Equitable development approaches typically work to prevent direct displacement, and in cases where relocation is unavoidable, fair monetary compensation for tenants is viewed as an important part of an equitable policy. For consistency, we refer to African Americans and Latinos, although in some of the original research, these groups were referred to as Blacks and Hispanics. Atlanta BeltLine Equitable Development Plan. The Equitable Development Workshop has been a feature of the New Partners for Smart Growth Conference since 2010. Perhaps its most significant achievement to date has been the community benefits agreement ONE DC signed with two local developers, Ellis Enterprises and Four Points, for the redevelopment of Progression Place at 7th and S. In return for the community groups support for the project with the D.C. government, the developers made several commitments. @GwinnettSToPP is a parent-organized group working against #SchooltoPrisionPipeline practices. They agreed to set aside 20 housing units for families with incomes below 50 percent of the area median income and 31 of the housing units for families with incomes between 50 and 81 percent of the area median income. A city with an equitable distribution of great neighborhoods full of strong amenities that provide equitable access throughout. Equitable development draws on both environmental justice and smart growth and generally refers to a range of approaches for creating communities and regions where residents of all incomes, races, and ethnicities participate in and benefit from decisions that shape the places where they live. The current patterns of disparity by race had many causes, but a lack of organized power amongst communities of color in terms of decision-making authority, financial, and physical assets, or the capacity to organize and advocate for equitable outcomes is one cause that has very specific remedies. Smart growth, sustainable development, and other innovative approaches incorporate equitable development ideas. Using the learnings and resources from jurisdictions at the forefront will create pathways for the increased engagement of more jurisdictions. To remedy the effects of inequitable policies and practices, residents of disinvested neighborhoods need information, tools, resources, and authority to lead development efforts in their communities. The District generally, including several longtime distressed neighborhoods, has become whiter and wealthier. 2022 Othering and Belonging Institute. The partners are also in the process of adopting some Guidelines legislatively. Develop healthy and safe communities. It is a fair question to ask "how does equitable development differ from other place-based approaches?". The plan provides long-term guidance to help the City make decisions over the next 20 years about managing growth and providing services. This policy serves as a model of restorative justice that can be undertaken by local governments. The Unity Council organized the Fruitvale neighborhoods predominately Latino community throughout a process of protesting a proposed light rail park n ride, designing a mixed-use project, and ultimately controlling the development and operation of the project. What is success? Founder @DorianAHunter summed it up, We are more organized as a collective instead of just working as individuals. #GOPCThread, @LancasterPA leaders identified the need for a new non-profit to oversee & coordinate the citys work 2 improve equity outcomes & reduce poverty. The program is directed by community-developed neighborhood plans responding to displacement pressures resulting from the introduction of light rail service in southeast Seattle. Current Equitable Development Projects are prioritized in three neighborhoods with high levels of chronic and recent displacement risk as well as a history of disinvestment. What Is an Equitable Remedy? In particular establish regional the economic and equity case for areas (e.g. Implement a clear process for career advancement This can cause discomfort, fear, and frustration for us as representatives of institutions. Equitable development is defined as development activity with a triple bottom line, taking into account the interests of the business community and local developers, fairness in the treatment of employees, and sustainability in protecting and enhancing resources (human and others) in responding to an array of social and environmental needs. Racial equitywhen race can no longer be used to predict life outcomes, and life outcomes for all groups are improved. But first the document introduces some key definitions and a vision for the elimination of racial disparities and achievement of racial equity. Gentrification fueled displacement, higher foreclosure rates, and a large racial wealth gap are some of the impacts of this legacy. Some projects that have paid particular attention to equitable development issues are listed below. The Westside Specific Plan is the outcome of collaboration among community, environmental and local government interests to create a successful neighborhood planning process. The Urban Land Conservancy's (ULC) Erin Clark showed images of Vina, a new 150-unit affordable apartment building in Globeville, one of Denver's poorest neighborhoods. There are clear examples that demonstrate the application and potential of this approach for rebuilding America . This type of growth in neighborhoods with weakened social and financial ecosystems is especially more likely to produce racialized outcomes like the displacement of communities of color. Census data shows a cyclical pattern of white flight phenomenon and reinvestment in urban communities that has led to a diaspora of communities of color with weakened infrastructure spread throughout metropolitan regions despite those regions having a majority ofpeople of color.4 coupled with re-zoning lower density single-family neighborhoods with access to services and amenities to allow for greater variety of housing types and price points. Goals should be sourced by these vulnerable populations through a process that builds rather than drains their poweras is often the case in public planning processes. Equitable development principles hardly dominate urban and metropolitan economic revitalization today. Public and private investments, programs, and policies in neighborhoods that meet the needs of residents, including communities of color, and reduce racial disparities, taking into account past history and current conditions. Goal 1: Strong communities and people. One method of alignment is through equitable development. Great places with equitable access. A typical example of an equitable remedy is monetary loss. Community-led planning and development efforts are essential for development patterns that work for communities of color. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites. Equitable community development promotes opportunity and resilience. A city where all neighborhoods are healthy, safe, and afford their resident access to the key determinants of well-being promotes inclusion. JavaScript appears to be disabled on this computer. Build cultural competence and responsiveness among all stakeholders, and structure planning processes to be clear, accessible and engaging. and develop strategies to prevent gentrification from displacing existing communities.16 Equitable development is defined as development activity with a triple bottom line, taking into account the interests of the business community and local developers, fairness in the treatment of employees, and sustainability in protecting and enhancing resources (human and others) in responding to an array of social and environmental needs. The Bentway. Instead, they wanted BART to plan with them rather than for them. Examples Stem. Equitable transit-oriented development (ETOD) advocates that people of all incomes experience the benefits of dense, mixed-use, pedestrian-oriented development near transit hubs. #CommunityStewardsTrainingProgram trains youth in community organizing. Combating Gentrification Through Equitable Development By Kalima Rose The Fifth Avenue Committee (FAC) has worked for fifteen years to revitalize the lower Park Slope neighborhood of Brooklyn, building affordable housing, rehabbing dilapidated buildings and training residents to own cooperative businesses in the neighborhood. #NehemiahManufacturingCo in @OhioCincinnati practices second chance hiring of hard-to-hire and formerly incarcerated people & provides a social support team to help employees succeed @HartongDigital #GOCPThread, #NehemiahManufacturingCo formed a non-profit that eventually merged w/ @cincinnatiworks to expand the program throughout the region. In the fullest sense, this would include amending public policies to ensure that they promote equity; prioritizing investments to best support those who need it most; and retooling processes to best do this work, including communication feedback loops that hold us accountable to community priorities. The practice of jurisdictions underinvesting in some urban neighborhoods with high populations of people of color means these areas and populations have greater needs. Community-based organizations rose to meet the needs of specific cultural groups and neighborhoods. Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings. The ReGenesis Project easily reveals the connections between land use, environmental justice, and sustainability. The Framework, with its equity drivers and outcomes, functions as an analytical tool to guide implementation to reduce disparities and achieve equitable outcomes for marginalized populations. One potential unintended consequence of increasing housing choices in predominately white neighborhoods is the social and cultural isolation and assimilation of people of color as these areas desegregate. It also requires that government institutions make structural changes to address the history of inequality. But it certainly bears watching. Tools to preserve affordable housing choices include targeting public housing investments where gentrification is anticipatedlike transit-rich areas.19 This is known as an 'equitable interest.'. The purpose of this Agreement is to facilitate fun. Subscribe today and get a full year of NPQ for just $59. Regional solutions are needed to serve the needs and aspirations of a multi-cultural society that is becoming more diverse. Community Cornerstones and Seattle's Equitable Development Framework, Seattle Washington And these strategies require public agencies, including local jurisdictions, to recognize and embrace the critical role that public policy and decision-making play in facilitating growth and investment patterns. Gentrification is a nuanced process whose outcomes may be viewed as: Some scholars argue gentrification is goodbecause it contributes to job growth, a larger tax base, higher property values, and opportunities to expand services or offer new ones. The partners are working on implementing some of the Guidelines administratively with the City Planning and Building Department. Concerns about gentrification should not be interpreted as unwillingness to embrace change or new development. This will not solve the Districts affordable housing problem, but it could be an important step in the right direction. work within a coalition maintain perspective seek to understand your partners' have three to five key advisors perspectives and goals celebrate each success define the problem have a life have a plan with defined interim never think it's over and final goals never quit include community-building be flexible about For example, Caitlin Cahill . View this example. Healthy Development Guidelines, Oakland California. A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means youve safely connected to the .gov website. Such gentrificationmany with ONE DC prefer the term displacementis not unique to this community. This course provides an introduction to a broad range of analytical methods and techniques used in the field to understand communities. Require local community participation and leadership in decision-making to reflect a diversity of voices, including targeted strategies to engage historically marginalized communities. Equitable Development. "Meaningful involvement means that the public should have opportunities to participate in decisions that could affect their environment and their health, their contributions should be taken into account by regulatory agencies, and decision-makers should seek and facilitate the engagement of those potentially affected by their decisions. Bill, along with discriminatory real estate lending and marketing practices, gave white households billions of dollars in home equity as they fled to the suburbsgreatly disinvesting in many urban neighborhoods with high populations of people of color in the process. Equitable Development as a Tool to Advance Racial Equity, The Vision of the Othering & Belonging Institute. UN-2. A city where all neighborhoods are healthy, safe, and afford their resident access to the key determinants of well-being promotes inclusion. Several chronic racial and ethnic inequities resulting from lack of access to opportunity, including. DSNIs programs for resident leadership, youth mentoring, parent advocacy, and community organizing are just a few examples. It is more likely to be considered in areas where a high level of development and change is anticipated. This requires coordinated and comprehensive investments, policies, and protections to prevent displacement of vulnerable residents, businesses, and community organizations. This indicates the creation of opportunities for healthy vibrant communities so that the poor and local communities benefit from decisions, activities and systems that affect their neighborhoods. Make job descriptions accessible. EPA sees value in elevating this narrative because it draws attention to solutions from environmental justice actions. #LancasterEquityCDC was formed as an intermediary to fill this role. How can development be done differently to create equitable outcomes? This paper provides a policy framework for implementation strategies that advance equitable development. More detailed policies and tools are provided in Table 1 below. Fair treatment means that no group of people should bear a disproportionate share of the negative environmental consequences resulting from industrial, governmental, or commercial operations and policies. This strategy should include establishing clear and bold goals upfront for community stability and economic prosperity for vulnerable populations.12 A clear policy framework is helpful for developing, implementing, and measuring effective strategies. Some examples include: Seattle 2035 is the City of Seattles Comprehensive Plan for managing growth. Low-income, minority, tribal, and overburdened communities across the country are using these strategies, along with environmental justice and equitable development approaches, to design and build healthy, sustainable, and inclusive neighborhoods. He formed an organization called ReGenesis to represent neighborhood interests in cleaning up contaminated and abandoned property as well as revitalizing the surrounding community. | The Unified Collective (click image for link), #UnifiedCollective works to increase equity & inclusion in @Sprinfield_OH neighborhoods. Used together, these drivers have the potential to transform systems and shift from the current trajectory of growth that marginalizes many populations and compromises the diversity that makes communities strong. 2. The Riverline Equitable Development Framework. To learn about more concrete approaches to #Equitabledevelopment, check out the webinar we jointly hosted w/ @landpolicy. Evaluation for equitable development results This document is made up of a range of Evaluation Working Papers (EWP) focused on evaluation for equitable development. Comprehensive shared investment strategies tying housing, jobs, transportation, and cultural amenities together provide the most promising anti-displacement, pro-growth models of equitable development.20. For example, AI professional development tools might collect information about employees' completed training, performance assessments, development plans, participation, social relationships and other business activities. create, monitor, and report on equity measures. That approach should address the two major obstacles to achieving equitable outcomes related to development: 1) involuntary economic and cultural displacement of communities of color and 2) inequitable access for communities of color to the key determinants of social, physical, and economic well-being needed. To achieve this, equitable development approaches usually integrate people-focused strategies (efforts that support community residents) with place-focused strategies (efforts that stabilize and improve the neighborhood environment). This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again. Below are examples of how AI tools can support job seekers and employees with disabilities, recruiters, and staff responsible for diversity, equity, and inclusion. A growing cannon of research2 Strategy 1: Recognize and build on communities of color existing capacity for self-determination. #GOPCThread, Thats not all! Launched in Fall 2018 as the Institute's official podcast, Who Belongs? Commercial stabilization strategies include providing public mitigation funding for small businesses impacted by major infrastructure improvements11 National Environmental Justice Advisory Council, Environmental Justice, Urban Revitalization, and Brownfields: The Search for Authentic Signs of Hope, 2015 Equitable Development Workshop in Baltimore, MD (PDF), Creating Equitable, Healthy, and Sustainable Communities: Strategies for Advancing Smart Growth, Environmental Justice, and Equitable Development, Unintended Impacts of Redevelopment and Revitalization Efforts in Five Environmental Justice Communities, Breakthrough Communities: Celebrating the Victories of Environmental Justice and Planning, Environmental Justice: A New Model for Planning in Underserved Communities, Addressing Environmental Justice in Brownfield Communities, White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council.